View Topic

Like. That can apply to anyone who's still alive from that list.

I beg to differ.  Of those on the list who are participating and still alive, two of us didn't vote to lynch our last defender.

How could I possibly have known Evelynx was a defender? How could Eve possibly have known Robin was a defender?

That's dodgy logic and yo know it.

*you*

I won't deny that my logic is dodgy.  This late in a Werewolf game, particularly with the way this one is going, nearly all logic is dodgy.

Yet you "beg[ged] to differ," and then gave an admittedly dodgy reason for it.

While my logic is dodgy, the point stands that some of us didn't participate in yesterday's lynch of a defender.  This simply means that some of us warrant more consideration than others.

The psychopaths know who is of their own, and wouldn't have hesitated to help ensure the elimination of an Unknown.  This late in the game, voting against such an elimination would not be a wise idea.  Sure, Evelynx could have been the Wendigo, but for the Psychos, that's a risk worth taking.  Even if the we find out who the Wendigo is, we can't kill it until the Psychopaths are dead, giving the baddies plenty of time to work together and end the game.

Ergo, a Psychopath would not have voted against the Evelynx lynch.  Unless, of course, they wanted to make this very argument.  But I think even you'll agree that that's far-fetched.

I will also admit that the Wendigo was under no similar pressure to vote for Evelynx.  If the Wendigo believed Evelynx was a Psycho, as many good guys obviously did, the Wendigo could have voted against it to try and save her. Once again, though, the safer bet for the Wendigo is to bandwagon on the Unknown.

DEAD

Now I need some popcorn too.

While my logic is dodgy, the point stands that some of us didn't participate in yesterday's lynch of a defender.  This simply means that some of us warrant more consideration than others.

The psychopaths know who is of their own, and wouldn't have hesitated to help ensure the elimination of an Unknown.  This late in the game, voting against such an elimination would not be a wise idea.  Sure, Evelynx could have been the Wendigo, but for the Psychos, that's a risk worth taking.  Even if the we find out who the Wendigo is, we can't kill it until the Psychopaths are dead, giving the baddies plenty of time to work together and end the game.

Ergo, a Psychopath would not have voted against the Evelynx lynch.  Unless, of course, they wanted to make this very argument. But I think even you'll agree that that's far-fetched.

I will also admit that the Wendigo was under no similar pressure to vote for Evelynx.  If the Wendigo believed Evelynx was a Psycho, as many good guys obviously did, the Wendigo could have voted against it to try and save her. Once again, though, the safer bet for the Wendigo is to bandwagon on the Unknown.

[big]But I think even you'll agree that that's far-fetched.[/big]

Will I, now? The arguments you've been making have been at least as far-fetched, and when pressed for reasons, they invariably get backed up by poor logic and "gut-feelings."

For instance, what reason would I have had to initiate an Evelynx lynch-mob when I knew that so many other people would likely end up voting for her anyway? I could even have done a 180 and NOT voted for her to really mess with people's minds. Even while voting for her, she displayed the belief that I'm innocent. Knowing as I do what type of storm would follow if I initiated her mob and, as a psycho myself in this scenario, knowing what would happen if people found out she WASN'T a psycho (or the Wendigo, as is statistically likely), I would have had very little reason to initiate her mob, especially as I would have wanted allies who DON'T display the belief that I'm a psycho.

But I was on a roll with two psychos down, and as previously mentioned, Hannah and Eve's actions just didn't make any sense to me if they weren't protecting Crush, and I couldn't separate Hannah and Eve for reasons previously given. So I followed through with that train of thought. Why am I more suspicious than anyone else who jumped on that train? Hell, why am I more suspicious than someone who didn't jump on that train? A good number of innocents would still have thought lynching her was the best plan without my prodding.

DEAD

Right? You could make a movie out of this!

You're aware that Evey also thought Hannah was innocent and vigorously defended her, right? I'm not sure that her belief in your innocence is exactly a ringing endorsement.

It's not an endorsement, that's not why I bring it up. It's simply one extra player I wouldn't have had to worry about.

I think we're forgetting to wait until the night phase is over before we get too excited, cause we still need to see if the night phase reveals anything

But a goodie you would still have to eliminate sooner or later.

Lynch baddies, not goodies
Even though we seem to be very bad at that ;-;

Definitely later than sooner. Don't discard a tool while it's useful.