View Topic

It's infinitely better to have a 50/50 chance of saving a comrade, than having zero chance of it. If you and Hannah aren't tied, why would she have come in to save you?

And I really don't care about my suspicion anymore. Three games of Werewolf in which I keep being a suspect has made me quite apathetic to it. I'm going to play the game the way I always do or die trying.

I'd like to post a correction to an earlier post, Crushita was voted for by Aragonn before I voted. He didn't bold his vote so I missed it. =p

I still believe that at least one of the wolves was voting for Crushita, if not more than one.  What better way to prove your innocence than by sacrificing a comrade who was already suspected anyway?

This is a good point, I think it likely that in this last round at least 1 psychopath did vote for Crushita, once it became clear he was going down. If I can refute every piece of evidence except for this one (admittedly, this would be difficult), seems to me that would make everyone who voted for Crushita equally suspect.

For a wolf, it would have been a difficult opportunity to pass up. Vote for someone who would definitely be going down, and you're safe from suspicion for a few turns.

I'm not relying my vote for Crushita for my defense, but it is a fair point.

It's infinitely better to have a 50/50 chance of saving a comrade, than having zero chance of it. If you and Hannah aren't tied, why would she have come in to save you?

And I really don't care about my suspicion anymore. Three games of Werewolf in which I keep being a suspect has made me quite apathetic to it. I'm going to play the game the way I always do or die trying.

How many times have you died in those three occasions?

It's infinitely better to have a 50/50 chance of saving a comrade, than having zero chance of it. If you and Hannah aren't tied, why would she have come in to save you?

And I really don't care about my suspicion anymore. Three games of Werewolf in which I keep being a suspect has made me quite apathetic to it. I'm going to play the game the way I always do or die trying.

I can't speak for @HannahB, maybe she can.

And I really don't care about my suspicion anymore. Three games of Werewolf in which I keep being a suspect has made me quite apathetic to it. I'm going to play the game the way I always do or die trying.

Well, aren't we being a touch overdramatic?

So my question is, why am I more suspicious for my vote right, so the net effect of my vote was moving from a tie between Crush and Evelynx to Crush and North; the only way that would be preferable for defending Crush would be if I knew that Evelynx was also a wolf, and in that case I was defending her instead... If I was attempting to defend Crush I personally didn't do that great a job of it, as he just ended up in another tie...

I fail to see why this puts so much suspicion on me

Plus I saved Evelynx cause she's ma Bae

I survived until the end of each one of played, after being suspected in each one (and the wolves fanned the flames in each one). You reach a point where you accept it as a fact that you're going to have an uphill battle and move on. Just like Wintermoot accepted it as fact that he was going to die first for a long time.

Does that mean the fact that he hasn't died first shows a lot about the player base this time around?

Yeah, there are quite a few new faces, not predominately the same people who keep playing with a small amount of new people. The absence of Aaron Specter and aternox, for instance, is certainly giving this game a different feel.

I suspect HannahB more. Though Colby has drawn some of my suspicion as well.

Hmm. Why do you suspect Colby?

It's his attempts to get us to go back to the drawing boards and rethink everything. We have a lead, and I say we pursue it until we've hit a dead end.

@Aragonn - Out of everything I've done, that's what makes you suspicious of me? Most fascinating.  But I hold to the belief that pursuing leads to dead ends is pointless.  I'd rather pursue leads to results, and sometimes that means dismissing what you think you know and reevaluating everything.

@Wintermoot - What exactly is it that makes you suspect Laurentus? I seem to be unable to remember, and I currently lack the time to go dredging through 60 pages to find out.

@HannahB - To me, the reason you're more suspicious than Evelynx is your relative absence from discussion, particularly in relation to her.

I still try to keep up with all the things, I don't post very much, but that isn't just WW that's in general I havent made a lotta forum posts or even PMs as of late.

I'd like to say Evelynx and I are close, and she talks to me about what's going on in the game, I know she's been really enjoying it and I don't really want her to get killed out of the game, even though she said she wouldn't mind.
At the same time I didn't want to be responsible for any one specific person to be killed, because if that person was a friend then I know everyone would leap on me as a late vote for bandwagoning. So swapping Evelyn out as a potential loss, voting for who she was most suspicions of, and breaking the load across a tie seemed like a safe bet to me...

It's just bad luck really that North died and not Crush first time.

Hmm, that is a good point about Hannah, Colby.

One thing keeps bugging me, though. Hannah could just have left it a tie between Eve and Crush, since that would still have left Crush with a 50% chance of living, but she chose to bail Eve out. That just keeps bothering me, and I don't see a world in which, if Hannah is a psycho, Evelynx isn't. I mean, if Eve is a psycho, then Crush and Eve being drawn would have led to one of them definitely getting lynched, whereas with North, they had a 50/50 chance of saving Crush.

If Hannah isn't connected to Eve, then Hannah would have had exactly zero reasons to bail her out. The only other people who could be connected, and who would go to such lengths to save their partner, are the defenders. And if they are defenders, their intervention to save Crush would be exceptionally odd, and Eve would have had to make a really bad calculation (as she did claim to have messed up the vote count until I pointed out the mistake), in which case Hannah was obliged to bail her out as well.

So I don't see a world in which they're not connected. The possibility that they could be defenders certainly gives me pause, but lacking any other suspects, I'm going with Hannah when the day phase starts.