View Topic

IIRC it was HannahB and Evelynx who were the biggest defenders of Crushita. Shall we attempt to hunt one of them down too?

Yeah, but deciding which will be problematic.

@Pengu If I get scanned by the Seer and turn out to be a Friend or Defender, do I get added to some sort of PM group?

Yeah, but deciding which will be problematic.

¿Por qué no los dos?
I mean, one and then the other of course.

@Aragonn: If anyone is scanned as a good guy, they'll be added to the Seer's PM by me.  If anyone is scanned as a bad guy, well, I'd pray for that person when the time comes.   

Problem is choosing which one first. And if the one chosen turns out to be a Friend or another good guy, we can't risk lynching the other one too. Which means we'd be back to square one.

Well, in my opinion, Eve seems more suspicious, but that's just my opinion ;-;

I'd look at Hannah first here...she was the one that tipped that vote in favour of a tie.

And let's not forget what Colberius said last round about the number of votes Crushita was getting. It's likely that at least some of the psychopaths voted for Crushita, perhaps to try to throw us off their trail.

They're both suspicious to me.

Ohh, you're right ;-;
I'm not good at picking who to vote for...

Thing is, Eve was the one who made it possible. And she claims she was high and making a stupid decision, but I just don't buy that. In my experience, she's just too smart for it.

Hannah made it possible just as much if not more so than Evey...if it were just Evey, then there wouldn't have been a tie and things would have proceeded as they should.

Hm...Wintermoot-san is right...

Don't want to come off as overly defensive, but I didn't attempt to save Crushita, I just suspected North more than I suspected Crushita so I wanted the dice to determine which died. I now realize it flew in the face of the democratic process and wasn't my decision to make, but at the time I justified that by attempting to put myself at risk as well. It didn't pan at out that way, and I wish I hadn't done it.

It was a mistake... however, I would also point out that I was also one of the first people to cast suspicion on Crushita originally (not in round 1, but in the round before this one: see http://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=3255.msg62529#msg62529), when nobody else was paying attention to him. Wolves might sacrifice one of their own when it becomes clear they are on their way out, but why would I have cast suspicion on them when nobody was talking about him?

My voting record during that period, for the sake of transparency, was:
Voted for North
Voted for Crushita
Voted for North at the last second.

I think that this fits the profile of someone who suspected both North and Crushita, and then made a stupid mistake that only caused confusion and didn't really accomplish much, more than it fits the profile of someone who was trying to save a compatriot.

TL;DR If I wanted to save Crushita, I wouldn't have quoted voting records and wrote paragraphs of analysis in order to cast suspicion on him.

That concludes my opening defense. If anyone has additional concerns, I will respond to them.

I think that Crush voted for Evelynx, switching his vote from North, thereby meaning North had two votes, Evelynx 4 and Crush 5. Then Eve switched from Crush to North, meaning Crush had 4, Evelynx 4 and North 3. Then Hannah switched from Eve to North, meaning North had 4, Crush had 4, and Evelynx 3.

This rings the death knell for both Hannah and Eve in my opinion. Eve created the situation where she was tied with Crush, even after Crush had voted for her, and then Hannah came in and substituted North with Eve, whom, by the way, Eve had voted for as well. The entire things screams team effort.