View Topic

Why are you leaving NS?

Well, because I won't be able to play in the next one. In nine days, I'll be leaving NS.

Wait. So are you still playing this game? You haven't died.

As day dawned, the peasants and knights were met with a gruesome sight. Not one, but two of their party had been annihilated by the Black Knight and The Knight Who Says Ni.

The shrubber, a.k.a. Aaron Specter, had quite obviously been tortured to death by having 'Ni' said to him over and over again.

Sir Lancelot's servant, a.k.a. El Fiji Grande, had been stabbed once in the heart, and then fed to the killer rabbit. Only his bloodstained clothes remained.

But who among the party could be responsible for these heinous deeds?
Aaron Specter and El Fiji Grande both died during the night, and this is also the first time that anyone has died in this game during the night.

You now have 48 hours in this day phase. Happy voting!

...well then... So, anyone have any ideas? I'm gonna listen before voting this time. I don't wanna accuse anyone innocent.

I don't know...
Wintermoot I somewhat trust, same with Sapphiron (Have I commented on your Prussia avatar yet btw? I love it )

Everyone else I have a null read on... Except for maybe Pengu, I don't know why, but their posts seem a little off to me, but it's not enough to want to vote them up so idk...

Someone else probably has stronger opinions than I do.

How many people do we have left?

@Ayanhart Thank you!

@Aragonn I believe we have 10 alive players, including myself.

I'd like to remind everyone that Laurentus picked a new member to be a French Knight, so it can be any one of the peasants that wasn't a knight before.

So going into past posts to see who is the most suspicious to be one of the knights isn't the greatest idea since, as I said, they would have been a peasant before this phase.

However, that doesn't apply to neither the witch nor the Black Knight.

On those two notes though, does anyone have ideas as to who either of those two roles could be?  We may even be lucky in guessing correctly at the newly created French Knight. 

Just a note that I couldn't add another French Knight. I opted for one of the Knights Who Say Ni.

Just a note that I couldn't add another French Knight. I opted for one of the Knights Who Say Ni.

Well potato, potahto, same difference. 

@Pengu But looking at past posts could work since the black knight was afoot. Also the wolf-seer is a traitor right?

My list of suspicion:

Pengu for traitor/new wolf for trying to deflect
Sapphiron for Black knight/new wolf, because previous.

Innocents:
Aragonn because he had the same thoughts as me. I'm a good guy, so a bad guy is unlikely to think like me.

@Pengu But looking at past posts could work since the black knight was afoot. Also the wolf-seer is a traitor right?

My list of suspicion:

Pengu for traitor/new wolf for trying to deflect
Sapphiron for Black knight/new wolf, because previous.

Innocents:
Aragonn because he had the same thoughts as me. I'm a good guy, so a bad guy is unlikely to think like me.

Your logic is astoundingly lacking in that statement.

Because someone agrees with you, they're automatically good because you're good?

You do realize the best thing for a wolf to do is to act like a good guy, right?  They're going to try to blend in the best way possible by making everyone think they're a good guy.  This means agreeing with the good guys in what they say so that those same good guys will think that they in turn are good. 

If a bad guy is not doing that and making himself obviously look bad, then it'd be quite a short game. 

As for my statement, why would I be trying to deflect by saying "Hey you know, if you're trying to find the new wolf by looking into past posts, you're doing it wrong since they were given the title after the previous day/night phases" ?  That's not deflection, that's fact.  The new wolf previously was not a wolf, so in what sense would it make to look at their past posts and use that against them?  They were elected just in this phase, so anything from here to later is what should be looked at, and the only backtracking for suspicion from before this point should be in weeding out the witch/black knight.

On that note, your post on me seems like a sorry attempt to put me as a bad guy, and your logic for supporting it and the person on your list makes zero sense.

That tells me that either:

A) You're an innocent that has obviously never played this game before.
B) The Witch, and you know Aaragonn is "good" because you scanned and know his role
or C) The Knight of Ni or Black Knight that is simply grasping at straws to avoid suspicion, even though nobody as far as I recall has even named you as a possible suspect yet.

However, I'm willing to bite.

Vote: Send YumYum36 to the bridge

I'm thinking Yumyum36 is just the village idiot (no offense). There's no need to go all out on him for a highly illogical statement. As you've previously stated, it would be a short game if the wolf made it abundantly clear who he/she is. Let's all calm down and use our heads.

I'm thinking Yumyum36 is just the village idiot (no offense). There's no need to go all out on him for a highly illogical statement. As you've previously stated, it would be a short game if the wolf made it abundantly clear who he/she is. Let's all calm down and use our heads.

I will agree with this.  However, I will also say that we have roughly 29 hours before the phase ends, so if there are better suspects to list, then I'll be urging people to speak up.