View Topic

However I must ask, aternox - what do you make of the relative silences of The Candy Lane and taulover, especially with regards to Sauron?

I'd take Sauron at face value and accept his inactivity is due to him not being here. I think TCL being quiet would be because of the same reason. Taulover being quieter is not surprising as they are a new players and often new players don't say much in their first game while they learn how to play.

It doesn't absolve any of them from potentially being a wolf, but it does mean that their inactivity isn't innately too suspicious to me.

Of the three people up for vote, Laurentus is the one which has the highest chance of being a wolf from my perspective.

Vote Lynch: Laurentus

...

Care to elaborate?

I didn't see Laurentus's last post before I posted.

Laurentus (and anyone else), if you are willing to switch your vote to someone who hasn't been voted for yet I will switch to them to. Colb maybe, he has been a been a bit quiet and if he saw us trying to pick between villagers it would make sense for him to lie low this phase and let us lynch one of our own.

Don't take this as me thinking Laurentus is 100% innocent, but I am willing to give him a bit of a chance for now in case he is a defender.

When I went to bed last night, I wasn't expecting to wake up and find more walls of text. I can't reply to any of the posts right now thanks to school. However, since we have 2 hours and 30 minutes left to vote, I don't believe I have the time to hesitate or delay ...

An interesting strategy. I'm not saying I agree, but who would be up for that? This would cast a bit of a different light on aternox.

I must still ask why your post was so inconsistent, though, as it's useless to lie about you remaining a prime suspect in my eyes until I get clarification on that.

Which post are you referring to? My first one of this phase was just mentioning I wasn't suspect of you before, and then I was a bit. My inclusion of Sauron was just me trying to include everything I could think of.

Yes, I'm referring to your first one of this phase.

But commentary on the posts I've made regarding that post would also be welcome, as I'm trying to get a sense of how you think and react.

My first reaction to the terms proposed by aternox was

My first reaction to the terms proposed by aternox was

As was mine, but perhaps we shouldn't judge him based only on his first one.

You pointed out that I didnt have much against you when I accused you. It's harder to catch a wolf by themselves in my opinion so we are better off starting by looking at pairs of people. You and Saph seem to be working together and in general I feel defenders try to avoid making any accusations that could make them a target. It seems to me wolves are more likely to be active because they can kind of claim that a wolf would want to fly under the radar.

The two of you have kind of been hinting you are defenders and no one has directly opposed that so I'm willing to give you a bit more time so that we don't screw things up for our team.

I also don't think Amalya is a wolf which mmeans the three options currently available are all innocent. The best move in my opinion is for us to lynch someone else.

I don't really like this but if we are just trying to find a dummy to lynch, I will go ahead and Vote: Send The Candy Lane to Duel since he will be removed from the game either way.

You pointed out that I didnt have much against you when I accused you. It's harder to catch a wolf by themselves in my opinion so we are better off starting by looking at pairs of people. You and Saph seem to be working together and in general I feel defenders try to avoid making any accusations that could make them a target. It seems to me wolves are more likely to be active because they can kind of claim that a wolf would want to fly under the radar.

The two of you have kind of been hinting you are defenders and no one has directly opposed that so I'm willing to give you a bit more time so that we don't screw things up for our team.

I also don't think Amalya is a wolf which mmeans the three options currently available are all innocent. The best move in my opinion is for us to lynch someone else.

Suppose I agreed with your assessment (which I don't completely, as it's still light on motivation for ruling Amalya out, and doesn't point out why your original post seemed so contradictory), who would you want to lynch, and why?

1 hour and 25 mins left.

1 hour and 25 mins left.

In that case. Vote: Send The Candy Lane to duel

I still expect a satisfactory answer in the next day phase, but we'll have more time to debate then. So if you'll vote to lynch The Candy Lane right now, then we have a deal. For now.

I really hope Yugi gets more involved in the next day phase, and uses his night phase to scan wisely now.