View Topic

Wait, clue wise, are you saying the person irl is male or the character?

Yes.

How very unhelpful.

Clues are generally meant to be vague and unhelpful in singularity. 

Somebody killed my brother Valerian! We must seek vengeance for his death.

Hmm. Of course who would be more enthusiastic to kill Taulover then somebody who knows his strength and the threat he poses?

I'm not going to vote for anyone, yet.

I'm going to assume that losing a Guardian was bad.  I'm still trying to get the hang of how this game works, so I'm not 100% sure, but their description makes it seem like losing one or both of them would put the good guys in a really bad place.

I'm going to have to think on this a bit.  Since I don't really know anyone, I don't know exactly who I would even vote for.

I too shall post to say that I have seen so far and am disappointed in Aragonn's vote day one.  I'd be far more nefarious and part of the game if I were a wolf

Sorry to disappoint you with a totally random vote when there was absolutely no evidence that anyone could be a wolf. You know how the early game plays out. Somebody has to die (usually), and it's always up to RNGsus to decide. I just increased the pool for RNGsus to pull from.

I too shall post to say that I have seen so far and am disappointed in Aragonn's vote day one.  I'd be far more nefarious and part of the game if I were a wolf

Hmm. You made an interesting choice there by trying to show your innocence with just "I'd be far more nefarious and part of the game if I were a wolf "

You could have not been very active to try to prove your innocence, but that would be a very cliche tactic, so I don't know what to think.

You could be the Grand Wolf hinting at your identity. I'm not going to vote for you yet because I can't really tell if you're a wolf or not yet.

Welp, only about a day left.

I'll Vote: Hydra as I believe he and Fayt are the only two that still haven't posted yet.

Well we really don't have much to go off of here. I guess I ought to go with my initial suspicions. As I said before Aragonn would probably be the one most likely to want to kill Tau in the first place, and his quickness to swear revenge is itself suspicious to me.
Vote: Aragonn

Well, since others are voting and someone needs to get lynched, I'll vote Robin because of his earlier claim about being disappointed about Aragonn voting for him. I thought the fact that he brought it up was suspicious and that he tried to show his innocence.

You made an interesting choice there by trying to show your innocence with just "I'd be far more nefarious and part of the game if I were a wolf "

You could have not been very active to try to prove your innocence, but that would be a very cliche tactic, so I don't know what to think.

You could be the Grand Wolf hinting at your identity. I'm not going to vote for you yet because I can't really tell if you're a wolf or not yet.

Well, since others are voting and someone needs to get lynched, I'll vote Robin because of his earlier claim about being disappointed about Aragonn voting for him. I thought the fact that he brought it up was suspicious and that he tried to show his innocence.

#Logic
But in all seriousness I'll vote for Aragonn mostly as he voted for me Day 1 and didn't mention RNGesus as the vote's raison d'etre.  Also because Crushita raises quite compelling arguments.  Plus I never use RNGesus.  It's too risky a tactic, especially for a Valerian, especially for a Valerian in the early game.

I didn't want it to come to this on Day 2, but I must vote for someone to save my own hide. Question is though do I want BSR gone or Hydra. I'll Vote: BraveSirRobin because of his insistence that I be a wolf purely for jumping in so soon. Did it ever occur to you that I have the notifications turned on and I happened to be available at the time he died? Also, it's too risky of a play for a Valerian to target another Valerian because of our past games. Patterns should not be followed from Werewolf to Werewolf. Whoever targeted Tau is obviously trying to frame a Valerian. And what greater threat within the Valerian house than me? Amazing plot idea, I do say.

I suppose I should vote, though I don't know who I should vote for.  At the same time, Mathyland brings up a good point about BraveSirRobin's interesting choice of phrasing.

I guess since I'm saying that, I guess I should just Vote: BraveSirRobin.

I hope my guess is correct.

I'll vote Aragonn again...someone's waayyyyy too defensive.