Pages: [1] 2

Raising Minimum Age for Tobacco to 21?
Posts: 16 Views: 986

Wintermoot
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • The Greyscale Magi-Monk
  • I ran into an article about Oregon's Senate approving a bill that would raise the minimum age for buying and possessing tobacco products from 18 to 21...if ultimately adopted, Oregon would become the third US state to do this, after Hawaii and California.

    Which leads me to wonder...is this an appropriate tactic from governments to combat tobacco use? What are your thoughts?


    I went all the way to Cassadega to commune with the dead
    They said "You'd better look alive"
    Wintermoot
    • The Greyscale Magi-Monk
    • Posts: 19,332
    • Karma: 9,613
    • Weather: ❄️
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Orientation
      Demisexual
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Doc
  • Citizen
  • I think it's a bad idea. It'll make it harder for kids to get ahold of, sure, but it'll also make it more attractive simply on the basis of 'this is fun stuff adults are keeping away from me'.
    A far better way to eliminate tobacco use is to simply jack up the cost. Slap tariffs on anything to do with it as a 'luxury tax' (even if it's much more of a 'sin tax'), and kids simply won't be able to afford it.
    If a pack of cigarettes costs $50, you could let them buy it at eight years old and the incidence of youth smoking would still crater.
    Proud Burner
    Doc
    • Posts: 1,518
    • Karma: 1,963
    • it's karma, man
    • Citizen
    • Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Red Mones
  • Citizen
  • Wintreath's Official Money Launderer
  • Ha! All Liberal wacko states! :P
    Red Mones
    • Wintreath's Official Money Launderer
    • Posts: 7,005
    • Karma: 2,202
    • Citizen
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Familial House
      Burdock
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Mathyland
  • Citizen
  • Wintreath's Potato Archbishop and Official Grammar Police
  • I think it's a bad idea. It'll make it harder for kids to get ahold of, sure, but it'll also make it more attractive simply on the basis of 'this is fun stuff adults are keeping away from me'.
    A far better way to eliminate tobacco use is to simply jack up the cost. Slap tariffs on anything to do with it as a 'luxury tax' (even if it's much more of a 'sin tax'), and kids simply won't be able to afford it.
    If a pack of cigarettes costs $50, you could let them buy it at eight years old and the incidence of youth smoking would still crater.

    Although, if the price is high, adults who can afford it and are addicted will go through all of their money even quicker.
    Résumé

    Hogwarts NS:

    Co-WA Delegate: June 13, 2016-present
    Hufflepuff student: April 9, 2016-present
    House points earned: 7 (Also, 40 points were a group effort, so I earned part of that as well)
    Host of Death Eaters II

    Wintreath:

    Citizen: September 6, 2016-present

    Underhusen Terms
    The 21st Underhusen
    The 22nd Underhusen
    The 23rd Underhusen - secretary
    The 24th Underhusen
    The 25th Underhusen
    The 26th Underhusen
    The 27th Underhusen

    Other:

    NationStates nation: March 11, 2016-present

    [/i]
    Mathyland
    • Wintreath's Potato Archbishop and Official Grammar Police
    • Posts: 2,937
    • Karma: 681
    • Citizen
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Familial House
      Valeria
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Doc
  • Citizen
  • Addiction isn't an on/off switch, it's a spectrum. They can cut back over time - there would probably be a pretty dramatic cutback at least initially, but supplemented with (probably copious amounts of) nicotine gum, it could get them into the spot where they might actually be able to kick the habit themselves.
    Nor am I suggesting we take cigarettes from, what, $10 a pack (gross oversimplification since IIRC my brother bitched about New York costing $15 a pack while Tennessee is more like $7 or 8) to $50 overnight, since that would be widely derided as 'something something federal overreach, something something freedoms, something something my body my choice'. But gradually phasing in higher and higher tariffs over a decade is something fully achievable.
    Although obviously for maximum effect either the first or second jump needs some real teeth, like a 100, 150% tax. But subsequently jacking it up 20% here, another 25% there...I think that's doable.

    Of course, I also think we should do that will alcohol, since that kills a shitload of people every year too, but that would be just too deeply unpopular. Republicans and Democrats alike would probably get together to lynch me if I proposed that, since it would affect white guy beer just as much as white girl wine, and they're the ones who lynch people.
    It'd be the unifying moment this country has been praying for.
    1 person likes this post: BraveSirRobin
    Proud Burner
    Doc
    • Posts: 1,518
    • Karma: 1,963
    • it's karma, man
    • Citizen
    • Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Gerrick
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • Addiction isn't an on/off switch, it's a spectrum. They can cut back over time - there would probably be a pretty dramatic cutback at least initially, but supplemented with (probably copious amounts of) nicotine gum, it could get them into the spot where they might actually be able to kick the habit themselves.
    Nor am I suggesting we take cigarettes from, what, $10 a pack (gross oversimplification since IIRC my brother bitched about New York costing $15 a pack while Tennessee is more like $7 or 8) to $50 overnight, since that would be widely derided as 'something something federal overreach, something something freedoms, something something my body my choice'. But gradually phasing in higher and higher tariffs over a decade is something fully achievable.
    Although obviously for maximum effect either the first or second jump needs some real teeth, like a 100, 150% tax. But subsequently jacking it up 20% here, another 25% there...I think that's doable.

    Of course, I also think we should do that will alcohol, since that kills a shitload of people every year too, but that would be just too deeply unpopular. Republicans and Democrats alike would probably get together to lynch me if I proposed that, since it would affect white guy beer just as much as white girl wine, and they're the ones who lynch people.
    It'd be the unifying moment this country has been praying for.
    The thing about that, though, is that it'd more strongly affect poor people as people below the poverty line are twice as likely to smoke, making the poor poorer. I'm not sure how likely they'd just switch to nicotine gum. It might do more harm than good overall.

    I think the amount of anti-smoking teaching and advertisements the government and public schools do is more effective. Young people are smoking tobacco less than older generations. And if legislation were able to be passed that removes branding on packages, I think that'd be good, too, but supposedly it infringes on the First Amendment.

    But on the whole age limit thing, that's a difficult question. I think I might support it. If you're able to buy it when you're younger, then you'd probably get addicted sooner. If you have to sneak around to get it, then you'd be less likely to have a continuous supply to feed that addiction.

    Duke of Wintreath and Count of Janth
    Patriarch of the Noble House of Burdock
    Curriculum Vitae
    Citizen: 15 November 2015 - present
    Recruitment Contest Winner: December 2015
    Recruitment Contest Winner: January 2016
    Secretary of the 14th Underhusen: 8 February 2016 - 8 April 2016
    RP Guild Councillor: 9 February 2016 - 24 February 2017
    Recruitment Contest Winner: April 2016
    Wintreath's Finest: April 2016
    Ambassador to Nesapo: 5 July 2016 - 13 March 2017
    Jarl of Culture: 30 November 2016 - 13 September 2019
    Wintreath's Finest: November 2016
    Wintreath's Finest: February 2017
    Count of Janth: 17 September 2017 - present
    Patriarch of the Noble House of Burdock: 17 September 2017 - present
    Recruitment Contest Winner: September 2017
    Duke of Wintreath: 13 September 2019 - present
    Wintreath's Finest: September 2019
    Skrifa of the 37th Underhusen: 8 December 2019 - 8 February 2020
    Wintreath's Finest of the Year: 2019
    Commendation of Wintreath: 27 June 2020
    Citizens' Council Member: 14 September 2020 - 8 March 2021
    Skrifa of the 43rd Underhusen: 9 December 2020 - 8 February 2021 🔥

    Alder of the Riksraad: 7 June 2021 - 17 June 2021
    Jarl of Culture: 17 June 2021 - 14 November 2021
    Alder of the Riksraad: 14 November 2021 - 1 March 2022
    Regional Stability Squad: 27 February 2023 - present
    Gerrick
    • Posts: 4,094
    • Karma: 3,256
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Orientation
      Bisexual
      Familial House
      Burdock
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Chanku
  • Citizen
  • Personally, I'm of the mind that if you can die for your country at 18, and be considered an adult (for the most part) at 18, then you should also be able to do things like smoke or drink.
    See you later space cowboy.
    Old Signature

     
    Current Positions in Wintreath
    Matriarch of House Kaizer
    Speaker of the 29th Underhusen
    Advisor to the Riksråd
    Positions I've held
    Riksrad(1st Jarl of Information, 3rd Jarl of Foreign Affairs, 2nd Jarl of Defense)
    Member of the WHR
    Speaker of the Underhusen (3rd)
    Speaker Pro Tempore of the Underhusen (1st)
    Underhusen Member (1st-3rd)
    Member of the 5th Overhusen
    Chairman of the 5th Overhusen
    6th Underhusen
    Speaker of the 6th Underhusen
    Mandate Holder for Jarl of Defense
    Member of the 8th Storting (Underhusen)
    Royalty of Wintreath
    Ambassador for the Department of Foreign Affairs.
    Underhusen Terms I've been a part of
    1st Underhusen
    2nd Underhusen
    3rd Underhusen
    6th Underhusen
    8th Underhusen
    Overhusen Terms I've been a part of
    5th Overhusen
    Families I've been a part of
    Kaizer - Matriarch (REFORMED)
    Kestar - Child of Wintermoot (REMOVED)
    Chanku
    Gerrick
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • I think they should raise the age for serving in the military to 21 as well. Too many kids recruited out of high school to go die or get fucked up because they didn't know better. By 21, I think many would.

    Duke of Wintreath and Count of Janth
    Patriarch of the Noble House of Burdock
    Curriculum Vitae
    Citizen: 15 November 2015 - present
    Recruitment Contest Winner: December 2015
    Recruitment Contest Winner: January 2016
    Secretary of the 14th Underhusen: 8 February 2016 - 8 April 2016
    RP Guild Councillor: 9 February 2016 - 24 February 2017
    Recruitment Contest Winner: April 2016
    Wintreath's Finest: April 2016
    Ambassador to Nesapo: 5 July 2016 - 13 March 2017
    Jarl of Culture: 30 November 2016 - 13 September 2019
    Wintreath's Finest: November 2016
    Wintreath's Finest: February 2017
    Count of Janth: 17 September 2017 - present
    Patriarch of the Noble House of Burdock: 17 September 2017 - present
    Recruitment Contest Winner: September 2017
    Duke of Wintreath: 13 September 2019 - present
    Wintreath's Finest: September 2019
    Skrifa of the 37th Underhusen: 8 December 2019 - 8 February 2020
    Wintreath's Finest of the Year: 2019
    Commendation of Wintreath: 27 June 2020
    Citizens' Council Member: 14 September 2020 - 8 March 2021
    Skrifa of the 43rd Underhusen: 9 December 2020 - 8 February 2021 🔥

    Alder of the Riksraad: 7 June 2021 - 17 June 2021
    Jarl of Culture: 17 June 2021 - 14 November 2021
    Alder of the Riksraad: 14 November 2021 - 1 March 2022
    Regional Stability Squad: 27 February 2023 - present
    Gerrick
    • Posts: 4,094
    • Karma: 3,256
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Orientation
      Bisexual
      Familial House
      Burdock
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Wintermoot
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • The Greyscale Magi-Monk
  • I was opposed to minimum ages when I posted this topic, but I didn't know if it was effective or not, so I did some looking up. According to the Illinois Department of Health, 90% of smokers start before the age of 18, and the average age of a new smoker is 13. So not only do minimum age laws interfere with an adult's ability to be an adult and make decisions for themselves (even stupid decisions), they're not even very effective and as Doc mentioned may actually be counter-productive.

    And don't get me wrong, when someone my age or younger tells me they've started smoking or using tobacco, I think they're stupid as shit...to know all that we know about it now and still start doing it. But on the other hand, I can't blame older generations that smoke, because none of that information was out there when they started...in fact at one time cigarettes were advertised as being healthy and recommended by doctors.

    And that's partially why I'm against adding special taxes on it as well...not only are you essentially taxing the poor because they're more likely to smoke, you're punishing older generations for a decision they made based on false information put out by tobacco companies. And even if it's for their own good, I don't know that it's right to tell someone in that situation that either they need to quit or they're going to give shitloads of their money to the government. It's not helping people with an addition...it's abusing people with an addition.

    Besides, the recent health care mess in the US should be enough to clue people in that politicians generally do not care about your health. When they talk about how these taxes improve people's health, it's just a convenient cover that sounds nice in order to tax the poor some more.


    I went all the way to Cassadega to commune with the dead
    They said "You'd better look alive"
    Wintermoot
    • The Greyscale Magi-Monk
    • Posts: 19,332
    • Karma: 9,613
    • Weather: ❄️
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Orientation
      Demisexual
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Doc
  • Citizen
  • I dunno. If we view things through that lens, then sure, anything that could disproportionately affect the poor is implicitly terrible. But then sales tax is pretty much how a lot of states are staying afloat, and that's regressive as all hell. Not to mention payroll tax, or hell, even income tax, since the wealthy are actualizing their gains not from salaries but from capital-gains-taxed, err, capital gains.
    And hitting it with a tariff is, in my view, the most effective way to disincentivize this behavior, simply because using basic economics principles, 1) we're already not taxing them for the negative externalities they're causing, and 2), any change in the price will have quite an alarming effect on the demand. Yes, there are some people who are 2-packs-a-day addicted, and they're not going to see that big a change in their consumption simply because they have a physiological need for it. But the people who are social smokers? Who smoke maybe a pack a week? A hit to the wallet might say 'eh, maybe once every fortnight', or price them out entirely.
    At some point, we have to accept that it's inherent to public policy that you can never perfectly account for everyone in your policy, and I'm okay with causing some relatively small part of the population some financial hardship if it saves another, larger part of the population from ever picking up smoking in the first place. I'm okay with the 'greater good' argument in cases like this simply because I doubt the efficacy of the alternative (age limits), and doing nothing at all is arguably a far worse evil in the first place. Policies can be tweaked at a later date, but inaction is hard to get moving out of.
    1 person likes this post: Sapphiron
    Proud Burner
    Doc
    • Posts: 1,518
    • Karma: 1,963
    • it's karma, man
    • Citizen
    • Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Red Mones
  • Citizen
  • Wintreath's Official Money Launderer
  • Damn, you guys don't belong on the internet. You're too calm! I need to see some RAGE!!!
    3 people like this post: taulover, Mathyland, Sapphiron
    Red Mones
    • Wintreath's Official Money Launderer
    • Posts: 7,005
    • Karma: 2,202
    • Citizen
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Familial House
      Burdock
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    taulover
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • Seeker of Knowledge
  • Damn, you guys don't belong on the internet. You're too calm! I need to see some RAGE!!!
    Welcome to Wintreath!  (*)  :P
    2 people like this post: Red Mones, Mathyland
    Résumé
    Wintreath:
    Citizen: 8 April 2015 - present
    From the Ashes RP Game Master: 29 November 2015 - 24 July 2018
    Skydande Vakt Marshal: 29 November 2015 - 28 February 2017
    Skrifa of the 13th Underhusen: 13 December 2015 - 8 February 2016
    RP Guild Councillor: 9 February 2016 - 6 March 2018
    Ambassador to Lovely: 23 February 2016 - 17 August 2016
    Werewolf VII co-host: 11 May 2016 - 5 June 2016
    Skrifa of the 18th Underhusen: 8 October 2016 - 7 December 2016
    Ambassador to Balder: 1 December 2016 - 1 March 2022
    Skrifa of the 19th Underhusen: 7 December 2016 - 9 February 2017
    Ambassador to the INWU: 11 March 2017 - 1 March 2022
    Ambassador to the Versutian Federation: 18 August 2017 - 22 March 2018
    Thane of Integration: 29 September 2017 - 7 March 2018
    Speaker of the 24th Underhusen: 10 October 2017 - 7 December 2017
    October 2017 Wintreath's Finest: 4 November 2017
    Speaker pro tempore of the 25th Underhusen: 9 December 2017 - 7 February 2018
    Wintreath's Finest of 2017: 6 January 2018
    Werewolf XIV host: 20 January 2018 - 23 February 2018
    February 2018 Wintreath's Finest: 5 March 2018
    Thane of Embassy Dispatches / Foreign Releases and Information / Foreign Dispatches: 7 March 2018 - 15 March 2020
    Speaker of the 28th Underhusen: 10 June 2018 - 7 August 2018
    Second Patriarch of the Noble House of Valeria: 10 October 2018 - present
    Arena Game 6 Host: 28 December 2018 - 9 March 2019
    Librarian of the Underhusen: 29 January 2019 - 12 February 2019
    Speaker of the 32nd Underhusen: 12 February 2019 - 8 April 2019
    March 2019 Wintreath's Finest: 4 April 2019
    Librarian of the Underhusen: 12 April 2019 - 23 October 2020
    Commendation of Wintreath: 24 September 2020
    Peer of the Overhusen: 9 December 2020 - 8 February 2021
    Vice Chancellor of the Landsraad: 26 May 2021 - 15 September 2022
    Arena Game 8 Host: 10 June 2021 - 19 July 2021
    June 2021 Wintreath's Finest: 5 July 2021
    Regional Stability Squad: 28 February 2023 - present
    Minecraft Server Admin: 8 March 2023 - present

    Aura Hyperia/New Hyperion:
    Plebeian: 16 April 2014 - 21 July 2014
    Patrician: 21 July 2014 - present
    Adeptus Mechanicus: 24 October 2014 - 16 November 2014
    Co-founder of New Hyperion: 29 October 2014 - present
    Lord of Propaganda: 16 November 2014 - present
    Mapmaker for Official Region RP: 27 November 2015 - present
    WACom Delegate: 11 November 2017 - present
    Other positions: Hyperian Guardsman, Hyperian Marine (Rank: Scout)
    taulover
    • Seeker of Knowledge
    • Posts: 13,189
    • Karma: 4,243
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Familial House
      Valeria
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    pacsironeenk
  • Former Citizen
  • I think the minimum age should be scrapped and replaced with a maximum age. Of -1,000,000.
    pacsironeenk
    • Posts: 260
    • Karma: 72
    • Former Citizen
    • Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Ogun of Valeria
  • Citizen
  • Popetato of Wintreath
  • i think that they should raise the minimum age. Tobacco does crazy things to your brain and it is hardly used for medicine. Soon people only in their early 20s will be going to jail or diagnosed with mental illnesses
    Spoiler
    Wintreath
    Potato Pope of Wintreath from September 9, 2020-December 2020 (stepped down and pledges support to true pope)
    Citizen of Wintreath from July 1, 2017-present
    Bishop of the Cathedral of the Holy Tuber from August 15, 2020-September 9, 2020
    Wintreath's Finest of June: July 7, 2020
    WA Vice Delegate of Wintreath from April 13, 2020-June 4, 2020
    WA Delegate of Wintreath from June 4, 2020-present
    Thane of World Assembly/Regional Affairs from June 9, 2020- present
    Skrifa of the 37th Underhusen from December 8, 2019-February 8, 2020
    Skrifa of the 38th Underhusen from February 8, 2020-April 8, 2020
    Skrifa of the 41st Underhusen from August 8, 2020-October 9, 2020
    Skrifa of the 42nd Underhusen from October 9, 2020-December 8, 2020
    Speaker pro-tempore of the 41st Underhusen from August 18, 2020-September 13, 2020
    Acting Speaker of the Underhusen of the 41st Underhusen from September 13, 2020-October 9, 2020
    Ambassador to The East Pacific from January 27, 2020-present
    Ambassador to Aerium from February 2, 2020-March 24, 2020
    Ambassador to India from March 24, 2020-present
    Ambassador to Sonindia from June 2, 2020-present
    Member of the House of Emoticonious from June 5, 2020-July 18, 2020
    Member of the House of The Devils from June 19, 2020-present
    Member of the Cathedral of The Holy Tuber from June 21, 2020-present
    Ogun of Valeria
    • Popetato of Wintreath
    • Posts: 497
    • Karma: 443
    • Citizen
    • Pronouns
      He/Him/His
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
    Michi
  • Regional Stability Squad
  • Level 167 Caticorn God of Destruction
  • As we all know, raising the minimum age doesn't do a damn thing except make it more appealing to those who are under that age limit.  Otherwise, we wouldn't have so many kids still in their school years having people buy them cigarettes to dance around the current age law of 18.

    Same goes for alcohol, and for all of the high school kids who get access to it for parties despite it being a 21+ thing.
    My Wintreath Resumé
    Michi
    • Level 167 Caticorn God of Destruction
    • Posts: 7,195
    • Karma: 4,052
    • Wintreath's Official Video Game Enthusiast
    • Regional Stability Squad
    • Pronouns
      Any except it/its
      Orientation
      Michisexual <3
      Familial House
      Valeria
      Wintreath Nation
      Logged
     
    Pages: [1] 2